The Detective's Handbook: Catching the Spy
Ask Smart, Listen Hard, Strike Fast
As a Civilian (Non-Spy), you have two jobs: Find the Spy and Protect the Location. It's a delicate balance. If you're too obvious, the Spy wins. If you're too vague, you look like the Spy. This guide will teach you how to walk that line perfectly.
📈 Detective Skills:
- Questioning: How to ask "inside" questions.
- Observation: Spotting the Spy's tells.
- Timing: When to accuse and vote.
🔍 Chapter 1: The Art of the Question
Your questions are your weapon. Use them to signal to other Civilians that you are "one of them" while confusing the Spy.
The "Inside Joke" Technique
Ask about something specific to the location's experience, not its physical appearance.
- Location: Airplane
- Bad Question: "Are we high up?" (Too obvious)
- Good Question: "Do you hate the food they serve here?" (Implies airline food, but could be a cafeteria or prison).
The "Role-Play" Question
Address the other player as if they are in their role.
- Location: Hospital
- Question: "How long have you been on shift?"
- Why it works: If they answer "I'm just visiting," it might be suspicious if everyone else is working there.
👀 Chapter 2: Spotting the Spy
Spies are under pressure. Look for these common stress signals.
The "Stall"
If someone takes too long to answer a simple question, they might be frantically scanning the location list.
The "Generic" Answer
Spies love answers that apply to everything.
- "It's okay."
- "I'm not sure yet."
- "It depends."
If someone gives three generic answers in a row, suspect them.
The "Mirror"
Watch for players who just repeat the sentiment of the previous speaker. They are trying to blend in without adding new information.
⚖️ Chapter 3: When to Accuse
Don't rush! You need a unanimous vote. If you accuse too early without evidence, you create chaos.
The "Soft" Accusation
Instead of stopping the game, use your question to pressure them.
- You Say: "Hey [Suspect], your last answer was really vague. Can you be more specific about why you're here?"
If they crumble under pressure, then you stop the game and vote.
⏭️ What's Next?
Refine your skills with these advanced guides:
- The Art of the Question - Deep dive into interrogation.
- The Spy's Survival Bible - Know your enemy.